Dive Brief:
- The Biodegradable Products Institute is defending its yearslong push to allow compostable packaging in compost used for organic agriculture. The trade group has made multiple attempts to petition the U.S. Department of Agriculture for the change.
- Last week, a new coalition launched pushing back against BPI’s federal advocacy campaign. The Safer Soils for All Coalition, which includes major haulers and the California Compost Coalition, argued that compostable packaging posed too many problems for composters.
- BPI Executive Director Rhodes Yepsen said the coalition was “the waste industry dressed up in composter clothing.” He emphasized that BPI is not seeking to require composters to accept compostable products, but merely to allow their use in organic agriculture, a key end market.
Dive Insight:
While the new Safer Soils for All coalition includes several commercial composters, other operators in the sector, including Black Earth Compost, Blue Earth Compost, Garbage to Garden, Earth Matter, Compost Now and Veteran Compost previously signed a letter supporting BPI’s petition. That letter, sent to the USDA in February, urged the agency to issue an interim final rule weighing in on the definition of compost, which would trigger a public comment period and “create a robust administrative record.”
The USDA did not respond to a request for comment on BPI’s petition for an interim final rule. The agency has indicated it will gather more information through an advanced notice of proposed rulemaking early next year. Yepsen contends the move is not needed, but said BPI continues to urge the agency to make regulatory changes.
Yepsen said the new coalition is “making noise” to distract from large haulers’ investments in depackaging and processing equipment that creates agricultural products out of a slurry, rather than compost products.
“These coalition members are trying to protect an investment that has nothing to do with organic farmers or even compostable products,” Yepsen said.
Much of this debate is centered on California, by far the nation’s largest compost market. California’s AB 1201, passed in 2021, would forbid products not allowed for use in organic agriculture from using a “compostable” label. Given the federal uncertainty, packagers fear almost all products developed as compostable would be forbidden from using the label in the state, cutting off a key market.
The state also requires businesses and households to separate their organic waste at the curb, creating a growing amount of feedstock for composters or anaerobic digestion facilities. Some companies, including WM, have deployed organics processing equipment to accept food waste largely from commercial businesses and process it into a slurry, which is sent to anaerobic digestion facilities.
Certain other composters have also used such a slurry, which Yepsen contends can pass contaminants through to the finished product.
Some stakeholders have argued that accepting compostable products can create a contamination issue due to consumer confusion regarding what counts as compostable. But Yepsen said the issue is related to education and infrastructure, not the use of compostable products.
“Contamination is a major issue for composters, but I don’t see what’s allowed in organic agriculture or not have anything to do with contamination,” Yepsen said.
Yepsen also pushed back on the coalition’s criticism of BPI’s compostability standard. BPI allows products that can take up to 180 days to biodegrade to be considered compostable, but the coalition said that that timeframe was too long, since some commercial composters end their process after just 60 days.
But Yepsen noted the 180 days was used in a laboratory setting, and that products typically break down much more quickly in commercial compost conditions. He added that the composting process should be measured by the stability and maturity of the compost itself rather than a specific time frame.
As for AB 1201, the law is now scheduled to go into effect on June 30, 2027, after regulatory agency CalRecycle delayed its implementation. Yepsen said the agency can further delay the law’s implementation as the regulatory process plays out at the USDA, and he hopes CalRecycle will again push it back.