Compliance penalties associated with Washington state’s minimum recycled content requirements declined again in 2025, even as the 2021 law’s obligations began to increase.
The Washington Department of Ecology announced it fined 38 plastic producers nearly $247,000 for being out of compliance in 2025 with a nation-leading law requiring certain PCR thresholds in trash bags, single-use beverage containers, and packaging for household and personal care products. That last category was new in 2025.
It’s the third year that the department has issued penalties to businesses, ranging this year from $131 to $43,381 “based on how much the producer has missed the mark” in meeting minimum PCR requirements. About 70% of obligated producers met minimum requirements in 2025, the agency said. The department broke out a list of eight companies whose fines exceeded $10,000.
“Overall, we’re seeing exactly what Washington was hoping to achieve, which is an increase in the use of recycled content across a variety of different packaging formats,” said Kate Bailey, chief policy officer for the Association of Plastic Recyclers, which advocates for recycled content policy to bolster markets.
Even as PCR thresholds and the number of covered plastic product categories has risen, total fines have fallen, meaning “even more companies are using more recycled plastic instead of new plastic, so I think it's a really good sign of progress,” she said.
Ocean Spray Cranberries received the largest fine this year at more than $43,000. The food and beverage company again used no recycled content in its covered containers. Ocean Spray did not respond to a request for comment.
Other top penalties for including zero or nearly no PCR went to Harvest Hill Beverage Co., a nearly $33,000 fine, Uline at nearly $24,000, and Tree Top at more than $20,000.
The department said in its latest release that producers may receive reduced penalties if they enter into an agreement with Ecology explaining why they were unable to meet requirements and presenting a timeline to come into compliance.
“Ecology’s goal is 100% compliance,” spokesperson Dave Bennett said in an email. He said the reasons for non-compliance are not obvious.
“Agency staff work with producers to help them comply, but producers are not required to share their reasons for non-compliance,” he said. “To overcome this, Ecology staff are considering if a producer survey would provide the best insights. It is not a legal requirement of the law, so responses would be voluntary.”
Bailey noted that Washington allows producers to seek exclusions, so non-compliance is “not excusable at this point” and “unfair to businesses that are complying.”
“It is very disappointing to see some of these repeat offenders,” Bailey said. “Their peers are using recycled content, so it's not necessarily a technical limitation.”
Washington’s 15-year PCR ramp-up
Still, Washington is “absolutely a leading state on this and really a global leader,” Bailey said, with widely applicable lessons on including incorporating reasonable phase-in timelines and waiver opportunities, and following through with enforcement.
California has required plastic beverage containers covered by the state bottle bill to contain a minimum amount of PCR since 2022. APR championed legislation that passed in California this year to raise noncompliance penalties from 20 cents to 30 cents per pound.
“Given the difference between new plastic and recycled plastic, just pushing those fees a little bit higher could be useful, for sure,” Bailey said. Fees could be higher in Washington, Bailey said.
The California bill also took a page out of Washington’s book and added public reporting on compliance, to begin in 2028. “I've heard from companies [saying], ‘we don't want to be on that list in Washington,’ so we know it works,” Bailey said.
APR wants to see PCR requirements expanded in Washington. The organization is working to introduce a bill in 2027 that would require recycled content in more types of items, Bailey said, namely more film and flexible plastics. It would also target opportunities beyond packaging to durable goods, such as a household recycling bin or storage container.
“We want to make sure that as we start to collect more film and flexible plastics, that we have strong markets to use them,” she said.
Additional collection could be spurred by Washington’s forthcoming extended producer responsibility for packaging program. Bailey called Washington’s recycled content and EPR laws together a “one-two punch.”
“Their EPR program starts in 2030, so now they’ve already got the recycled content. They know as they start to collect more containers through EPR it will go right back on their shelves in these types of products,” Bailey said. “I think it's just a really good model for how they're looking at closing the loop.”